{"id":5195,"date":"2010-12-31T11:43:34","date_gmt":"2010-12-31T11:43:34","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/?p=5195"},"modified":"2011-03-21T13:18:36","modified_gmt":"2011-03-21T13:18:36","slug":"a-riddle-wrapped-in-a-mystery-inside-a-balls-up","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/?p=5195","title":{"rendered":"A riddle wrapped in a mystery inside a balls-up"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>Consider #2 on the Mori-Mukai list of rank-3 Fano 3-folds.\u00a0 This has been giving us some difficulty, which I have now resolved.\u00a0 We were making a combination of mistakes.\u00a0 Mori and Mukai describe the variety <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/021\/02129bb861061d1a052c592e2dc6b383-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='X' title='X' class='latex' \/> as follows.<\/p>\n<p style=\"padding-left: 30px;\">A member of <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/2c0\/2c0fedb4ef75fd4f55c95183a1990bb0-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='|L^{\\otimes 2} \\otimes_{\\cO_{\\PP^1 \\times \\PP^1}}  \\cO(2,3)|' title='|L^{\\otimes 2} \\otimes_{\\cO_{\\PP^1 \\times \\PP^1}}  \\cO(2,3)|' class='latex' \/> on the <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/fc4\/fc40778b711617ef146a3ec76339a0d5-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='\\PP^2' title='\\PP^2' class='latex' \/>-bundle <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/330\/330c70cef429d948c8b5fe206f5bcbbd-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='\\PP(\\cO \\oplus  \\cO(-1,-1)^{\\oplus 2})' title='\\PP(\\cO \\oplus  \\cO(-1,-1)^{\\oplus 2})' class='latex' \/> over <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/ce3\/ce3a4dc55f03066aea89d98807261acd-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='\\PP^1 \\times \\PP^1' title='\\PP^1 \\times \\PP^1' class='latex' \/> such that <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/9b0\/9b02871a98303ec2e3d15663ed6ef6b9-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt=' X \\cap Y' title=' X \\cap Y' class='latex' \/> is irreducible, where <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/d20\/d20caec3b48a1eef164cb4ca81ba2587-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='L' title='L' class='latex' \/> is the tautological line  bundle and <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/57c\/57cec4137b614c87cb4e24a3d003a3e0-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='Y' title='Y' class='latex' \/> is a member of <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/28d\/28d5256eb61c0054aac4d6f733e0b6f5-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='|L|' title='|L|' class='latex' \/>. <strong><\/strong><\/p>\n<p>Our first mistake, as Mukai-sensei pointed out in an email to Corti, was using the wrong weight convention for projective bundles.\u00a0 Mori and Mukai use negative weights, so the  ambient <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/fc4\/fc40778b711617ef146a3ec76339a0d5-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='\\PP^2' title='\\PP^2' class='latex' \/>-bundle <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/800\/800618943025315f869e4e1f09471012-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='F' title='F' class='latex' \/> is the toric variety with weight  data:<br \/>\n<img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/d27\/d27cdea066e651f166cbb8f1aaf6058c-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='\\begin{array}{cccccccc} x_0 &amp; x_1 &amp; y_0 &amp; y_1 &amp; t_0  &amp; t_1 &amp; t_2   &amp;   \\\\ 1 &amp; 1 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0  &amp; 1  &amp; 1 &amp; \\\\ 0&amp; 0 &amp; 1 &amp; 1 &amp; 0  &amp; 1  &amp; 1  &amp; \\\\ 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0&amp; 1  &amp;1 &amp; 1  &amp; \\end{array} ' title='\\begin{array}{cccccccc} x_0 &amp; x_1 &amp; y_0 &amp; y_1 &amp; t_0  &amp; t_1 &amp; t_2   &amp;   \\\\ 1 &amp; 1 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0  &amp; 1  &amp; 1 &amp; \\\\ 0&amp; 0 &amp; 1 &amp; 1 &amp; 0  &amp; 1  &amp; 1  &amp; \\\\ 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0&amp; 1  &amp;1 &amp; 1  &amp; \\end{array} ' class='latex' \/><br \/>\nFor later convenience we change basis, expressing <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/800\/800618943025315f869e4e1f09471012-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='F' title='F' class='latex' \/> as the toric variety with weight  data:<br \/>\n<img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/ad7\/ad7befd48c8077fe511611a2b57d2f7b-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='\\begin{array}{cccccccc} x_0 &amp; x_1 &amp; y_0 &amp; y_1 &amp;  t_0  &amp; t_1 &amp; t_2   &amp;   \\\\ 1 &amp; 1 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; -1   &amp; 0  &amp; 0 &amp; A \\\\ 0&amp; 0 &amp; 1 &amp; 1 &amp; -1  &amp; 0   &amp; 0  &amp; B \\\\ 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0&amp; 1  &amp;1 &amp; 1   &amp; C  \\end{array} ' title='\\begin{array}{cccccccc} x_0 &amp; x_1 &amp; y_0 &amp; y_1 &amp;  t_0  &amp; t_1 &amp; t_2   &amp;   \\\\ 1 &amp; 1 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; -1   &amp; 0  &amp; 0 &amp; A \\\\ 0&amp; 0 &amp; 1 &amp; 1 &amp; -1  &amp; 0   &amp; 0  &amp; B \\\\ 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0&amp; 1  &amp;1 &amp; 1   &amp; C  \\end{array} ' class='latex' \/><br \/>\n<img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/021\/02129bb861061d1a052c592e2dc6b383-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='X' title='X' class='latex' \/> is a section of <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/31f\/31fca6b929b2bb66436f582faac03b1a-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='|B+2C|' title='|B+2C|' class='latex' \/>.<\/p>\n<p>Our second mistake was failing to accurately account for the fact that although <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/021\/02129bb861061d1a052c592e2dc6b383-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='X' title='X' class='latex' \/> is Fano, the bundle <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/f31\/f31da0941a2c4ba35a49cdf3415ccae4-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='A+C' title='A+C' class='latex' \/> (which restricts to <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/11a\/11ae53979e91e43edb5ebf9f4edd5302-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='-K_X' title='-K_X' class='latex' \/> on <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/021\/02129bb861061d1a052c592e2dc6b383-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='X' title='X' class='latex' \/>) is <em>only semi-positive<\/em> on <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/800\/800618943025315f869e4e1f09471012-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='F' title='F' class='latex' \/>.\u00a0 Thus we are in the situation described in <a href=\"http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/?p=5153\">this post<\/a> and, in the notation defined there, we have:<br \/>\n<img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/76d\/76d484d574b73773322d9068137b524c-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='\\begin{cases} F(q) = 1 \\\\ G(q) = 2q_3+6q_2 q_3 \\\\ H_1(q) =  \\sum_{b&gt;0} {(-1)^{b} \\over b} q_2^b = {-\\log(1+q_2)} \\\\ H_2(q) = {-\\log(1+q_2)} \\\\  H_3(q) = \\log(1+q_2) \\end{cases}' title='\\begin{cases} F(q) = 1 \\\\ G(q) = 2q_3+6q_2 q_3 \\\\ H_1(q) =  \\sum_{b&gt;0} {(-1)^{b} \\over b} q_2^b = {-\\log(1+q_2)} \\\\ H_2(q) = {-\\log(1+q_2)} \\\\  H_3(q) = \\log(1+q_2) \\end{cases}' class='latex' \/><br \/>\nand hence:<br \/>\n<img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/14f\/14f6db7d66ad4e41c94857a3b47c6196-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='\\begin{cases} q_1 = {\\hat{q}_1 \\over 1 - \\hat{q}_2} \\\\ q_2 = {\\hat{q_2} \\over 1 - \\hat{q_2}} \\\\ q_3 = \\hat{q}_3 (1-\\hat{q_2}) \\end{cases}' title='\\begin{cases} q_1 = {\\hat{q}_1 \\over 1 - \\hat{q}_2} \\\\ q_2 = {\\hat{q_2} \\over 1 - \\hat{q_2}} \\\\ q_3 = \\hat{q}_3 (1-\\hat{q_2}) \\end{cases}' class='latex' \/><br \/>\nThus the cohomological-degree-zero part of the J-function is:<br \/>\n<img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/bcc\/bcc49bc00c82327d169e440c62021647-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='\\exp({-2}\\hat{q}_3(1-\\hat{q}_2)-6\\hat{q}_2 \\hat{q}_3)  \\sum_{a,b,c\\geq 0} \\hat{q}_1^a \\hat{q}_2^b  \\hat{q}_3^c(1-\\hat{q}_2)^{c-b-a} {1 \\over z^{a+c}} {(b+2c)! \\over a!a!b!b!c!c!(c-b-a)!}' title='\\exp({-2}\\hat{q}_3(1-\\hat{q}_2)-6\\hat{q}_2 \\hat{q}_3)  \\sum_{a,b,c\\geq 0} \\hat{q}_1^a \\hat{q}_2^b  \\hat{q}_3^c(1-\\hat{q}_2)^{c-b-a} {1 \\over z^{a+c}} {(b+2c)! \\over a!a!b!b!c!c!(c-b-a)!}' class='latex' \/><br \/>\nand setting <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/21d\/21d8957ad5909f48b5a5bbe70203902a-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='\\hat{q}_1 = t' title='\\hat{q}_1 = t' class='latex' \/>, <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/976\/976fa400f00eede5209f24dde0bcc7d6-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='\\hat{q}_2 = 1' title='\\hat{q}_2 = 1' class='latex' \/>, <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/81f\/81faee4d568bb51209f8e02e8016018e-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='\\hat{q}_3 = t' title='\\hat{q}_3 = t' class='latex' \/>, <img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/936\/9360d2c79de73e141e391d96ae0770ba-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='z=1' title='z=1' class='latex' \/> yields:<br \/>\n<img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/bf9\/bf91c58449a7a5996f1d66fed8d563f9-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='\\exp(-6t)  \\sum_{a,b\\geq 0} t^{2a+b} {(2a+3b)! \\over a!a!b!b!(a+b)!(a+b)!}' title='\\exp(-6t)  \\sum_{a,b\\geq 0} t^{2a+b} {(2a+3b)! \\over a!a!b!b!(a+b)!(a+b)!}' class='latex' \/><br \/>\nRegularizing this gives:<br \/>\n<img src='http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/wp-content\/latex\/99c\/99cd6d1e57ab5d5009245d6012f8ae09-ffffff-000000-0.png' alt='I_{reg}(t) =1+58 t^2+600 t^3+13182 t^4+247440 t^5+5212300 t^6+111835920 t^7+ \\cdots' title='I_{reg}(t) =1+58 t^2+600 t^3+13182 t^4+247440 t^5+5212300 t^6+111835920 t^7+ \\cdots' class='latex' \/><br \/>\nAs Galkin conjectured, this is period sequence 97.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Consider #2 on the Mori-Mukai list of rank-3 Fano 3-folds.\u00a0 This has been giving us some difficulty, which I have now resolved.\u00a0 We were making a combination of mistakes.\u00a0 Mori and Mukai describe the variety as follows. A member of on the -bundle over such that is irreducible, where is the tautological line bundle and [&hellip;]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":2,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[1],"tags":[5,10,3],"class_list":["post-5195","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-uncategorized","tag-data","tag-example","tag-theory"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/5195","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/users\/2"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcomments&post=5195"}],"version-history":[{"count":13,"href":"http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/5195\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":5391,"href":"http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/5195\/revisions\/5391"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fmedia&parent=5195"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcategories&post=5195"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/coates.ma.ic.ac.uk\/fanosearch\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Ftags&post=5195"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}